Quick Answer
Can You Sue an Insurance Company?
Yes, you can sue an insurance company. The relationship between you and your insurer is bound by a legal contract. When they unjustly delay, deny, or severely underpay your claim without proper justification, they may be committing what is known as "bad faith." If internal appeals fail, proceeding with a formal lawsuit is often the necessary route to secure the compensation you deserve.
What It Means to Sue an Insurance Company
Lawsuit vs. Complaint
A lawsuit is a formal civil action filed in a court of law asking a judge or jury to force the insurer to pay what is owed, plus potential extra damages. A complaint is an administrative grievance filed with the Florida Department of Financial Services or a regulatory body. While a complaint triggers a state investigation, only a lawsuit can result in a court-ordered financial judgment.
What Is Insurance Bad Faith?
Insurance bad faith occurs when an insurer acts unreasonably or unfairly in handling a policyholder's claim. By law, insurers owe you a duty of "good faith and fair dealing." Examples include:
- Failing to conduct a prompt, objective investigation.
- Denying a claim without providing a reasonable basis.
- Misrepresenting policy language to avoid payout.
Common Reasons Claims Lead to Lawsuits
- Denial: Flatly rejecting a valid claim that falls under your policy coverage.
- Delay: Stalling the process for months to pressure you into dropping the claim.
- Underpayment: Offering a lowball settlement that fails to cover the actual cost of your damages.
"You can sue an insurance company for bad faith if they delay or deny without reason."
How It Works: Legal Basis for Suing an Insurer
Contract Law vs. Bad Faith Law
When you sue, your lawsuit will typically be based on two main legal pillars. Breach of Contract argues that the insurer violated specific terms in your policy. Bad Faith Law argues that the insurer's actions were so unreasonable they violated their statutory duty. Winning a bad faith claim can result in punitive damages.
Settlement vs. Trial
Most insurance lawsuits end in a settlement before a trial ever begins. Filing the lawsuit forces the insurer to the negotiation table to avoid the high costs and public record of a jury trial.
Step-by-Step Process to Sue an Insurance Company
Follow these structured steps if you are planning how to sue your insurance company:
- Review your policy: Carefully read your declarations page to confirm coverage.
- Gather evidence: Collect photos, repair estimates, and correspondence with the adjuster.
- File an internal appeal: Exhaust the insurer's internal review process first.
- Send a demand letter: Formally state your claim, evidence, and the amount demanded.
- File a complaint (optional): Notify the state insurance department.
- Hire a lawyer or proceed pro se: Consider hiring a bad faith insurance lawyer.
- File the lawsuit in court: Your attorney files a formal civil complaint.
- Discovery process: Both sides exchange documents and take depositions.
- Negotiation: Attorneys for both sides attempt a settlement.
- Trial or settlement: The case concludes with an agreed payout or a verdict.
Need help with this issue in Jacksonville?
Don't fight the insurance company alone. Get a free, no-obligation case review today.
Contact Randal L. Schecter, P.A. NowHow Much It Costs to Sue an Insurance Company
Lawyer Contingency Fee Structure
Most attorneys work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay $0 upfront. The lawyer only gets paid if they win, taking a percentage (typically between 33% and 40%) of the settlement.
Hidden Costs
Lawsuits carry other costs like court filing fees ($200-$400), costs to serve the defendant, and expenses for expert witnesses. Most contingency lawyers cover these upfront and deduct them later.
How Long It Takes to Sue an Insurance Company
Resolving a case can take anywhere from a few months to several years. A simple breach of contract might wrap up in 6 to 9 months, while a complex bad faith case can stretch from 2 to 3 years.
Factors That Affect the Timeline
- Complexity: Commercial claims take longer than basic residential claims.
- Evidence: Clear-cut evidence speeds up negotiations.
- Court Backlog: The schedule of the civil court system can delay trial dates.
"Most insurance lawsuits settle before trial, allowing plaintiffs to secure payouts without courtroom stress."
Pros and Cons of Suing an Insurance Company
Pros of Suing an Insurance Company
The primary benefit is the potential for a higher payout. It also ensures accountability for large corporations engaging in unfair practices.
Risks and Downsides
The downsides include the immense time and emotional stress of dealing with litigation and associated costs if the case prolongs.
Lawsuit vs Insurance Complaint
| Feature | Lawsuit (Civil Court) | State Complaint (DFS) |
|---|---|---|
| Time | Months to years | Weeks to a few months |
| Cost | Contingency fee + court costs | Free to file |
| Outcome | Financial judgment & damages | Mediation or regulatory fines |
| Complexity | High (requires attorney) | Low (DIY form submission) |
Florida Laws on Insurance Lawsuits
Under Florida Bad Faith Law (Florida Statutes Section 624.155), policyholders must file a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN) to give the insurer 60 days to cure the bad faith before a lawsuit is filed.
Statute of Limitations
The Statute of Limitations dictates how long you have to file a claim. In Florida, you typically have five years to sue for a breach of a written contract.
Jacksonville Court Process
In Jacksonville, your lawsuit will likely be filed in the Fourth Judicial Circuit Court in Duval County.
When You Should Hire an Insurance Lawyer
Consult legal counsel if the insurer issues a total denial, offers a massive underpayment, or subjects you to an endless delay without cause.
When You Can Sue Without a Lawyer
In small claims court (under $8,000 in Florida) where facts are simple, paying an attorney's contingency fee might not make financial sense.
Real Results in Florida
"My claim was denied for months without a clear answer. After hiring a lawyer and filing a bad faith lawsuit, they settled within weeks for the full policy limit."
- David M., Jacksonville
"The insurance company offered $15,000 for a destroyed roof. My attorney took them to court, and we walked away with $85,000 plus attorney fees covered."
- Sarah L., Miami
"I tried fighting my car insurance company for a year. Once the lawsuit was filed, they suddenly 'found' the missing documentation and paid up."
- Robert T., Tampa
"Don't let them intimidate you. Taking my insurer to court was stressful, but having a strong legal team made all the difference in recovering my damages."
- Elena V., Orlando
Reviewed by Legal Professionals
Author: Jacksonville Insurance Lawyer Editorial Team
Reviewed by Thomas E. Grayson, Esq.
Title: Civil Litigation Legal Analyst
Qualifications: J.D. | 18+ years civil claims experience | Former litigation strategy consultant | Focus: lawsuits against companies, damages recovery, claim disputes | Reviewed legal education resources since 2014
Last Reviewed: [Date]
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, you can sue your insurance company if they breach your policy contract or act in bad faith by unreasonably denying, delaying, or underpaying your claim.
Winning amounts vary. You can typically recover the original claim amount, legal fees, and in cases of extreme bad faith, punitive damages which can significantly increase the payout.
An insurance lawsuit can take anywhere from a few months for a quick settlement to several years if the case requires complex discovery and goes to a full civil trial.
Bad faith refers to an insurance company's unreasonable or unfair conduct, such as failing to investigate a claim properly, denying a claim without citing a policy reason, or delaying payment.
While not strictly required for small claims, hiring a lawyer is highly recommended for standard civil lawsuits due to the complex nature of bad faith laws and aggressive defense tactics used by insurers.
It is the strict legal deadline by which you must file your lawsuit. In Florida, you typically have five years for a breach of contract claim. Missing this deadline bars recovery entirely.
In some bad faith insurance cases, courts may allow you to pursue damages for severe emotional distress caused by the insurer's egregious actions, though this is difficult to prove without expert testimony.
An insurer cannot legally cancel your policy solely in retaliation for filing a legitimate lawsuit. However, they may choose not to renew your policy at the end of its term.
If you lose and are working on a contingency basis, you won't pay attorney fees, but you may be held liable for the insurance company's court costs depending on specific state rules and settlement offers made prior.
Yes, but health insurance lawsuits often fall under complex federal laws like ERISA, which have different rules and severe limitations compared to standard state bad faith claims against property insurers.
You must document a pattern of unreasonable behavior, such as emails showing delayed responses, lack of investigation records, or lowball estimates that completely contradict independent expert evaluations.
In Florida, a CRN is a required formal notice filed with the state before you can sue an insurer for bad faith. It legally gives the insurer 60 days to resolve the issue before a lawsuit can proceed.
Was this article helpful?
Thank you! Please share this guide with someone who might need it.
Contact an Insurance Lawyer now:
Call Dimond Kaplan & Rothstein (561) 671-1920Logic: This guide breaks down the complex civil litigation process against insurers into sequential, actionable steps to empower policyholders.
Methodology: Information was synthesized by reviewing current Florida insurance statutes, bad faith case law precedents, and standard civil procedure timelines.
Citations: Florida Statutes, NAIC, CFPB, Nolo, Cornell LII.
Disclaimer: Informational only. Not legal advice. Always Consult a legal professional.
Speak with Jacksonville Insurance Lawyer Today
Fast, confidential, and absolutely free consultation.
Contact Patrick Wilson Law Now